Here you will find summarised trust law notes for the entire Monash University topic.
The summary notes are an excellent exam help, with steps to work through all topics. They contain relevant precedent and case citations for that HD answer, along with brief summaries of every case. They are short enough for use in an exam, but detailed enough that you will never miss a point....
The following is a more accessible plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Trusts Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:
Remedies
Beneficiary to elect which remedy at the time of judgment Tang Man Sit
No double recovery
Personal Remedies
Account (for the trust fund)
B can ask the T to render account to him/her at any time
Doesn’t necessarily have to be a breach of trust
The T must produce accounts showing receipts and disbursements “account in the common form”
It is suggested that the order of account suffices as a remedy in many cases where the T’s actions have caused loss. However, in cases where account is no longer practical (e.g. there is no trust asset involves, trust has come to an end) the remedy of EC is used
Once the account is made the B can either accept, surcharge, or falsify the account
If the B accepts it, they agree the B has acted properly
If they “surcharge” the trust, the B indicates dissatisfaction with the T’s management. The T must then account for the trust fund as if it were properly managed
The B “falsifies” the account where he or she believes that some of the trust fund has been misapplied. The T must then account for the full amount of the misapplied funds
If there is a breach, or potential breach:
Court will order account “on basis of wilful default”
Trustee must determine the extent the fund has been depleted, ascertain what would have been earned if the trust had been properly administered, and pay the B that amount
Equitable compensation for breach of trust (only for loss)
Sought where a trustee’s breach of trust has resulted in a loss to the trust (you find this out through account of the trust fund)
If equitable compensation is awarded, the trustee must restore the trust fund as if the breach had not occurred Re Dawson
It is not payable to beneficiaries personally Permanent v Perpetual UNLESS there is no point e.g. trust is wound up Youyang
Common sense ‘but for’ test of causation Canson
Foreseeability/remoteness questions do not arise as we are simply looking at the figure Re Dawson; Youyang (Have they breached? Yes. Reconstitute)
However causation may be more relevant if it is a breach of the conflict rule, as there must be a causal link between breach and loss
Damages to be assed at the date of judgment Re Dawson per Street J
However, another assessment date may be indicated if the fund would have stood at a higher level prior to judgment
Other factors that might/might not apply:
Contributory negligence not a defence at equity, particularly as the B’s are often in a very week position and can’t influence the outcome Alexander v Perpetual Trustees
BUT, consider Wrongs Act s 23A: Contribution can be recovered ‘whatever the legal basis of liability, whether tort, breach of contract, breach of trust or otherwise”
Seems like it is now your duty as T to consider the situation where you might be able to claim money from the B such as in Alexander
Exemplary damages not available Harris v Digital Pulse
Mitigation unlikely to be relevant as B rarely can actually take sensible steps to mitigate against loss
Account of profits made in breach of trust
Trustee must account to the beneficiary for any profit made from the trust Boardman
Doesn’t matter if the trustee made the profit honestly/dishonestly, intentionally/unintentionally, if the trust also benefited, or whether the P was able to make it themselves or not Boardman
Sufficient to establish that the illicit profit has been made in the context of a breach of trust. There is no extra causative link required
May (discretionary) make allowance for the trustee’s time, skills and effort, expenses. It is a question of NET profit Boardman
If the breach results in both a loss and profit. The P must usually elect between an account of profits to strip the loss, or equitable compensation to cover the loss. Tang Man Sit
Don’t have to elect this before trial
Unlikely to be used for misappropriation of an asset, but perhaps misappropriation of an opportunity
2. Proprietary Remedies
Proprietary remedies are important as they take the asset of the asset pool available to creditors. It also allows the B to claim particular property, especially as you are entitled to trace the property into the hands of others.
Constructive Trust: A trust is imposed by equity to satisfy the demands of justice and good conscience (regardless of intention) where it would be unconscionable for the legal owner of the property to retain the beneficial interest in the property.
Effect:
Whilst the trustee holds the legal title to the property, equity will view them as holding the property on trust for the beneficiary
The D becomes constructive trustee. Equity suspends the rights until legal title can be transferred to the P
P obtains a beneficial interest in the property (changes ownership) and then,...
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Trusts Notes.
Here you will find summarised trust law notes for the entire Monash University topic.
The summary notes are an excellent exam help, with steps to work through all topics. They contain relevant precedent and case citations for that HD answer, along with brief summaries of every case. They are short enough for use in an exam, but detailed enough that you will never miss a point....
Ask questions 🙋 Get answers 📔 It's simple 👁️👄👁️
Our AI is educated by the highest scoring students across all subjects and schools. Join hundreds of your peers today.
Get Started