This is an extract of our The Torrens System And The Principle Of Indefeasibility Policy document, which we sell as part of our Property B Notes collection written by the top tier of Monash University students.
The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Property B Notes. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:
The Torrens System and the Principle of Indefeasibility History of the Torrens system Introduction of the Torrens system (TS)?
First TS introduced by Real Property Acts 185861 (South Australia) by Robert Torrens Sources of ideas
? Merchant Shipping Act (Imp)
? UK Real Property commissioners' report 1857
? Hanseatic system of title registration (Dr Hubbe)
[5.1214] Robert Torrens was assisted in creating the system and it was not a radically new system as is sometimes claimed. Torrens system in Victoria?
Victoria had a system of deeds registration from the 1840s to the 1990s Torrens system introduced in Vic from 1862 and applied to
? all land granted from Crown after 2.10.1862, and
? all other land parcels voluntarily registered by their owners
Adopted under Real Prop Act, now under TLA. All States have the system although the basic features are the same. The legislation does go by different names in each State.
Objects of the Torrens system
[5.25] In the old system one weak link in the chain of title, unless cured by adverse possession, was sufficient to destroy or impair the title of the last person in the chain. The Torrens system was intended to authoritatively establish title by guaranteeing that the person named as proprietor had a perfect title subject only to encumbrances specifically noted on the register. Dealings, not documents, were registered. A dealing was not to be completed until registration (though an unregistered dealing is not without effect). The purchaser therefore has no need to investigate the history of the vendor's title. This principle ideally requires the register to reflect all facts bearing on the title of the proprietor, thereby reliving anyone searching title from the need to go beyond the register. The conclusiveness of the register is generally what is meant by the principle of indefeasibility.
[5.26] Objects of the system include
providing a register from which persons who propose to dela with land can discover all the facts relative to the title
to ensure that a person dealing with land subject to the system is not adversely affected by any infirmities in the vendor's title that do not appear on the register (thus avoiding the necessity of going behind the register to investigate)
to provide a guarantee by the State that the picture presented by the register book is true and complete o
if this is not true, compensation is to be paid to any person who suffers loss either through the land being made subject to the system or else through the register not disclosing all the facts relevant to the title
security of title and security of transaction??
Objects of Torrens system Promote security of title and security of transaction by Giving publicity to interests so that conflicts of property rights are less likely to occur Protects purchasers against risk of
? Unregistered prior interests, and
? defects in the chain of title Indemnifies those who suffer loss through Registry mistake or a rule of the systemMere fact of deed registration previously did not give priority over unregistered rights. The TS purports to overcome problems of notice. The TS is different in concept, form and operation: is a system of title by registration Registration under DRS did not change the nature of the interest (eq to legal etc) or cure title. On TSL registration confers legal title; it creates a central register containing individual interests. The State guarantees the accuracy of the register. TS does not change the types of interest available (eg CTs, life estates) - what changes is the method by which they pass.Legal interest: source is registration in most cases; it creates the rightTS replaces the chain of title of the documents by a single certificate of title with all registered interests that exist. This remains at the land titles office and the duplicate is held by the registered fee simple owner or by the first registered mortgagee.Much of the system has been computerised and the aim is the register will be solely computer entriesThe cert of title ordinarily must be produced when an instrument relating to that land is being registered; the registrar must ensure the information on the original and duplicate certs match. o
Vol and folio number: folio = pages, vol = the book volume in which the certificate is located. The last/newest owners name is on there at the end of the list.
Certificate = now referred to as a folio, duplicate = now referred to as the Certificate of Title
Bringing land under the system
[RG] How does land come under the operation of the Torrens legislation?
For many years, Part II of the TLA provided a means by which unregistered ('general law') land could be brought under the Torrens System. The conversion schemes laid down in Part II were underutilised. The Transfer of Land (Single Register) Act 1998 (Vic) amended the TLA to streamline and accelerate the conversion (ie registration) of general law land. It did so by substituting a new Part II in the TLA. Under the new s 8, all unalienated Crown land is deemed to be under the operation of the Torrens system and a new s 9 imposes a duty on the Registrar of Titles 'with all reasonable speed to bring under the operation' of the TLA all land already alienated by the Crown which is not under the operation of the Act. Other significant amendments include the closure of the deeds register established under various sections (4, 6 and 7) of the PLA; the repeal of all previously existing conversion schemes under the TLA; and introduction of additional means of conversion and the consequential introduction of two additional forms of title to Torrens land: provisional and identified folios.
[5.15] Earliest legislation provided that land alienated or granted by the Crown after the date of commencement was automatically to be under the Torrens system. This has been continued under current legislation (TLA s 8(1)).
[5.16] TLA s 108 requires an applicant to contribute to the assurance fund as a condition of the certificate being issued. This has the purpose of covering the risk of compensation of a person deprived of an interest by registration of the applicant's title.
[5.17] the Registrar processes the application and is entrusted with discretion to issue a title or not. An unsuccessful applicant may call on the Registrar to state the grounds on which the application has been rejected and may require that the grounds be substantiated before the court (TLA s 116).
[5.18] Certain persons (fee simple owner at law or equity; trustees for sale of land; person having the power to appoint or dispose of the fee simple estate) may apply to bring land under the TLA: TLA s 10. A mortgagor (holder of equity of redemption under the general law) cannot apoly without the consent of the mgee. The application must list all relevant docs in the applicant's possession or control, all known encumbrances/interests in the land, the occupant of the land and nature of occupancy, the names and addresses of the owners and occupants of all adjoining land (TLA Sch 2). The Registrar must give notice of the application by publication in a newspaper in the area and personally or by post to the occupier of the land and those of the surrounding land. The Registrar has power to and does give notice to persons identified in the application as having an interest in the land: TLA s 26U.
[5.19] Once these procedures have been complied with, the Registrar decides whether to issue a certificate of title to the applicant. Legislation appears to give the R a broad discretion: TLA s 26S. The applicant may appeal the decision or seek an order for mandamus to compel registration of title. The Registrar must investigate the title, but where the application is made on behalf of the application by a solicitor the Registrar may regard himself/herself as relieved from the obligatiom of verifying the matters that might otherwise require independent official investigation. A person claiming an interest in the land may lodge a caveat forbidding registration: TLA s 26R. They then have a certain period of days to institute proceedings in to establish the interest. If not instituted, the caveat lapses and a certificate of title may be issued to the applicant.
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Property B Notes.